• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Frugal Lancaster

Helping You Live a Frugal Life in Lancaster County, PA

  • Discounted Tickets
    • Adventure Aquarium
    • The Crayola Experience
    • Diggerland
    • Dutch Wonderland
    • Laserdome
    • Legoland
    • Philadelphia Zoo
    • The Works
    • Xtreme Air Trampoline Park
  • Field Trips
    • National Watch & Clock Museum
    • National Toy Train Museum
    • Julius Sturgis Pretzel Bakery
    • The Amish Farm and House
    • Railroad Museum of PA
    • Heritage Press Museum
    • That Fish Place
    • Maple Sugaring at Lancaster County Central Park
  • Maps and Guides
    • 30+ Places to Visit on Rainy Days in Lancaster County
    • 10 Fun Indoor Water Parks Near Lancaster County PA
    • 10 Fall Family Fun Things To Do in Lancaster County
    • A Map of Lancaster County Playgrounds
    • FREE Places to Go With Your Kids this Summer in Lancaster County
    • Mostly-Free Summer Bucket List Ideas for Your Family Staycation {with Lancaster County links}
    • Lancaster County Indoor Play Areas that are FREE!
    • FREE Petting Zoos in Lancaster County
  • Shopping Bargains
    • Discount Grocery Stores List
    • Pepperidge Farm Discount Store
    • How To Earn Money Grocery Shopping
    • Giant Gas Deals
  • Contact
    • Email Newsletter

How to Earn the Most Profit at Consignment Sales

How To Earn The Most Profit at Consignment Sales

These suggestions are based off of what I learned from selling at the Just Between Friends Consignment Sale. Your consignment sales may have different consignor fees or percentages. But many of the selling and pricing principles remain the same!

Work the closing shift, to have your $10 fee eliminated.

I did this for the Lancaster sale, but not the Reading sale, because of my schedule. Having done both, I decided that for me, I would rather pay the $10 fee. Why?

  1. I have to drive at least 20 minutes to each sale. Till I pay for the gas and the time to get there and back again, the $10 is not worth it to me, especially since I am going to the sale multiply other times throughout the week for drop off, pick up and the presale. If I lived closer, this might change my opinion.
  2. The clean up and tear down shift is hard work. I’m not trying to deter you from this shift.
    online pharmacy order soft cialis online with best prices today in the USA

    It was a great experience and I’m glad I did it, but it was long (6 hours). I was on my feet the whole time, moving and sorting items. Granted, I loved it too. There is something super satisfying about organizing.

    online pharmacy order wegovy online with best prices today in the USA

    But I was exhausted!There are definitely benefits though, like a free pizza break half way through your shift and sometimes they offer special $5 gift cards to places like Dunkin Donuts – to keep you moving and focused. Like whoever finishes sorting first!

  3. I really enjoyed working at checkout. I love meeting the people, seeing what they are buying, and tweaking my patterns and skills to be efficient as I can for the customer. That’s just who I am! I love it, its what I’m good at, and so I’ll stick with it. 😉

Work a shift, to earn an extra 10% on your sales.

This is the key! If you have a goal to sell $300 worth of items, then you’ll earn an extra $30 just by doing this step. And I love it, because you can choose from so many options.

buy amoxil online https://hiims.in/blog/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/jpg/amoxil.html no prescription pharmacy

Maybe you like to walk the floor and sort clothes. Maybe you like numbers, and people, so you want to work at checkout. Maybe you want to greet people to the sale. Maybe you want to help tear down and clean up. There are so many options and with each one you can make it a point to be observant at what is and what is not selling!

Set a goal.

My initial goal was $100. As I started pricing things and realized who much I had, I realized I probably needed to raise my goal.

Then, my goal became $300.

It was super motivating for me to have this goal set, especially as I entered my prices into the program and could see the value of how much I had entered so far. Don’t waste too much time thinking about what you could make if everything sold at full price, but I am a firm believer that it is ok to dream a little! Then come back to reality. 🙂

A lot of consignors like to set a goal of selling 80-90% of their items, which is another motivating option! Do what works for you.

Price higher than you think.

I talked a lot about pricing in my earlier post, but I will emphasize again—price higher than you think. (If you’re goal is to make a lot of profit. If you’re main goal is to get rid of stuff, then just price it for whatever you want to get for it.) But even if you simply price things $.50 to $1.00 more than what you think they should bring, you will still probably sell the item!

You may also want to read more about how I set my prices and what sold and what did not sell for me.

Carefully consider what you want to do with your items that don’t sell.

If you’re in it to make money, consider carefully what you might be able to sell on eBay, Facebook groups, at a yardsale or at the next consignment sale.

buy propranolol online https://hiims.in/blog/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/jpg/propranolol.html no prescription pharmacy

I priced some items too high, however I was glad I did. I ended up selling several clothing items on eBay for almost the same price as I tagged them for at the sale—but on eBay, you only pay 10% of your selling cost!

Presale Usually Nets About 30% of Your Total Items in Sales

Keep in mind that you typially sell 30% of your entire sales on the first presale day. Someone told this to me the first day I was selling at items at a consignment sale, and for me, this ended up being true!

At the end of the first day of the Reading sale, I had sold about 0.

online pharmacy order avana online with best prices today in the USA

By the end of the week, I had sold about $300. The same was true for Lancaster, but slightly less overall. All in all, I sold about $500 between both sales. The total listing price value for everything (that did and did not sell) was about $800.

Other articles in this series that might interest you:
How I Prepared for My First Consignment Sale
How I Priced My Consignment Sale Items to Earn a Healthy Profit
What Sold and What Did Not Sell
How I Tagged My Clothes and Why I Decided to Buy a Tagging Gun
My #1 First-Time Consignor Regret

Filed Under: Consignment Sales Tagged With: consignment sales, earn profit at consignment sales, jbf, just between friends

Did you love this post?

Want to receive more posts like this one in your inbox—and be the first to know about local deals, ways to save money and fun things to do in Lancaster PA?




Thank you!

Check your email right away. We just sent you a welcome letter with direct links to our most helpful resources in Lancaster County. And tomorrow you’ll get a neat little freebie from us. (Add frugal.lancaster@gmail.com to your address book if you’re having trouble getting the emails!)



  • Classical Conversations

Medieval Family Movie Night Ideas for CC Cycle 2

By Kathy /
Our family loves to enjoy family movie nights thanks to a change I made a few years ago after I...
Read More
Medieval Family Movie Night Ideas for CC Cycle 2
  • Lancaster County

Young Artist classes a la carte is back for 2022: Build your own art camp at the Center for Creative Exploration (PA College of Art and Design)

By Kathy /
This Summer the Center for Creative Exploration (CCE) is offering a buffet of diverse opportunities for weeklong and multi-day youth art classes...
Read More
Young Artist classes a la carte is back for 2022: Build your own art camp at the Center for Creative Exploration (PA College of Art and Design)
  • Classical Conversations

Africa: Morning Time Guide, Read-Aloud List and Family Movie Ideas

By Kathy /
A six-week morning time guide on Africa geography, history, literature, music, family movies and arts and crafts. As I was...
Read More
Africa: Morning Time Guide, Read-Aloud List and Family Movie Ideas
  • Lancaster County

Shopping Lancaster County Etsy Stores

By Kathy /
Support your local creators and vendors this holiday season, by checking out these local Etsy shops. I've made three collections...
Read More
  • Lancaster County

Refreshing Mountain Christmas Lights & Family Escape Room Experience

By Kathy /
Consider a gift of experience this year for the holidays and make some memories with those you love most. You...
Read More
  • Homeschool
  • Lancaster County
  • Local Events
  • Seasonal

7 Summer Theater Camps in Lancaster County

By Kathy /
If your child has the performance bug and wants to learn how to perform on stage, Lancaster County has no...
Read More
7 Summer Theater Camps in Lancaster County
  • Lancaster County

How We Save on Gas

By Kathy /
Where we live, we're about 20 minutes from almost everything. It's a blessing, because you can go so many places...
Read More
How We Save on Gas
  • Food
  • Lancaster County

How to Live Off Of Your Pantry for a Month

By Kathy /
For the month of January 2021, I completed my first ever pantry challenge. What is a pantry challenge? Simply put,...
Read More
How to Live Off Of Your Pantry for a Month
  • Classical Conversations

80+ Etsy Gifts for Classical Conversations Tutors

By Kathy /
I found myself down a little rabbit trail this weekend when I was searching Etsy for some tutor gift ideas....
Read More
80+ Etsy Gifts for Classical Conversations Tutors
  • Lancaster County
  • Recipes
  • Seasonal

Our Family’s Top 10 Favorite Sourdough Recipes

By Kathy /
During the COVID quarantine I saw so many people trying sourdough. I was interested, but it just wasn't the right...
Read More
Our Family’s Top 10 Favorite Sourdough Recipes

Primary Sidebar

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Search

Popular Posts

Medieval Family Movie Night Ideas for CC Cycle 2
10 Fun Indoor Water Parks Near Lancaster County PA
Empty Tomb Crescent Rolls {An Easter Family Tradition}
Redner's: FREE Betty Crocker Cake Mix AND $5 credit for your BTFE school
3 Ways to Save on Hershey's Water Works at the Hershey Lodge
Home Depot FREE Kids Workshop - Build a Bunny Basket {Saturday, April 1, 2017}

Facebook

Facebook

Footer

Frugal Lancaster posts may contain affiliate links, which means we might make a small percentage of sales made through our links (at no extra cost to you!) Please read our privacy policy for more details.

Copyright© 2026 · Brunch Pro Theme by Shay Bocks