• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Frugal Lancaster

Helping You Live a Frugal Life in Lancaster County, PA

  • Discounted Tickets
    • Adventure Aquarium
    • The Crayola Experience
    • Diggerland
    • Dutch Wonderland
    • Laserdome
    • Legoland
    • Philadelphia Zoo
    • The Works
    • Xtreme Air Trampoline Park
  • Field Trips
    • National Watch & Clock Museum
    • National Toy Train Museum
    • Julius Sturgis Pretzel Bakery
    • The Amish Farm and House
    • Railroad Museum of PA
    • Heritage Press Museum
    • That Fish Place
    • Maple Sugaring at Lancaster County Central Park
  • Maps and Guides
    • 30+ Places to Visit on Rainy Days in Lancaster County
    • 10 Fun Indoor Water Parks Near Lancaster County PA
    • 10 Fall Family Fun Things To Do in Lancaster County
    • A Map of Lancaster County Playgrounds
    • FREE Places to Go With Your Kids this Summer in Lancaster County
    • Mostly-Free Summer Bucket List Ideas for Your Family Staycation {with Lancaster County links}
    • Lancaster County Indoor Play Areas that are FREE!
    • FREE Petting Zoos in Lancaster County
  • Shopping Bargains
    • Discount Grocery Stores List
    • Pepperidge Farm Discount Store
    • How To Earn Money Grocery Shopping
    • Giant Gas Deals
  • Contact
    • Email Newsletter

Willow Street Living Nativity

This is a guest post written by Alli Swords, who lives in Lancaster County with her four children and husband, and who loves to write!

We had wanted take our children (ages 8, 6, 4, 2) to a live nativity this year, so when we saw the one at the Willow Street Mennonite Church being offered, we jumped at the chance to attend. We attended Saturday evening (opening night) and the evening could not have gone more smoothly!

The live nativity ran from 5:30 to 8:30 and it said in the event notes that light refreshments would be served before each 1/2 presentation. Since it was about a 35 minute drive for us, we decided arrive at 5:00pm. We pulled in around 4:55pm and people were just starting to arrive. We parked easily and were met by friendly people who showed us the way in. We stood outside the event room for about a minute before they allowed us to enter…handing each person in my family a purple ticket. This ticket, they said, would get us into the first 1/2 presentation of the night.

We had about 20 minutes until the live nativity would start, so we ate cookies, drank hot chocolate, and the kids colored, worked on word mazes, and sticker nativity books the church provided for them. It was just the right amount of time to not feel rushed!

By around 5:20, I would say this room was already filled and the first and second 1/2 presentation time slots were filled!  Right at 5:30pm, they had everyone with purple tickets come to another room. This is the only part of the night we felt rushed because we should have whisked the kids away from the activity table sooner. We were rushing to get jackets on, take last sips of cocoa, and clean up our table. Oops.

There was a small skit in this room, followed by a small skit in the sanctuary. From there, we walked (transportation was provided for those that needed it) across the street, down a muddy, puddled graveled path to a beautiful barn! After another small skit by the fire, we were led inside to an absolutely beautiful barn filled with lots of real live animals! Baby Jesus was even a REAL baby!!!

They had someone play a live song on guitar and the atmosphere was amazing. At the conclusion of this final skit, we boarded a large wagon pulled by a tractor to head back to the church. We arrived back at the church around 6:10pm. 

I highly recommend going to see this Live Nativity! It continues Sunday and Monday evening. My very busy two and four-year-old were “entertained” the entire time and my older kids really soaked in the message. The actors were excellent, the costumes great, and the story–well, that was perfect. 

Just a couple of notes to make your experience great…dress warm! The walk to the barn, and even inside the barn, was cold. The walk to the barn was muddy…wear old clothes and boots. The timing, especially for those with young children, was a little hard. The kids thought it was hilarious that we had cookies for dinner and a pizza-to-go for “snack.” GET THERE EARLY!!! When we pulled out of the parking lot, it was FILLED!! I was so glad we got there a little before 5pm.

A lady from the church told me they do this every other year, so if you miss this year, hopefully you can catch it again in 2020. I know we will! 

You can find out more about this live nativity in this post on Lancaster County Live Nativities. It’s the last listing in the post.

Model Train Displays
Here are the best places to find model train exhibits (many of them free!) in Lancaster County. Some start as early as November 24!

Live Nativities in Lancaster County
The experience of live nativities becomes immersive and brings the birth of Jesus Christ to life, right before your eyes!

Frysville Farms
For those who haven’t heard of Frysville, when they walk in to their store, they are surprised and excited to make it a new yearly family tradition!

Affordable Christmas Trees in Lancaster County
The price of Christmas trees continues to increase every year. Sometimes you’ll pay for the experience, but if you’re on a budget, you might need something a little more practical.

Where to Meet Santa in Lancaster County
This list includes breakfast with Santa, photos with Santa, Santa Christmas parties, cookies with Santa, and even a train ride with Santa!

Christmas Light Shows in Lancaster County & Beyond
Here are 10 light shows for you to enjoy with your family! (Some are large productions with a fee, others are free neighborhood houses or by donation.)

32 Unique Ways to Celebrate Christmas in Lancaster
On this list of ways to celebrate Christmas you’ll find live nativities, candlelight tours, christmas light shows, garden tours, concerts and even scooter rides with Santa!

Experience Gift Ideas in Lancaster County
I’ve come to learn that one of the best types of gifts you can give kids is experience gifts. Experiences that will create memories lasting a lifetime.

Experience Gift Ideas for Girls
This holiday season a friend asked me about experience gift ideas for a six year old girl. I had a lot of fun brainstorming and coming up with ideas for this mom, so I thought I’d share what I found with you too!

Staples Holiday Cards Deal
A few years ago we started purchasing holiday cards through this Groupon deal—here’s our experience and why we love it!

sugared cranberries recipe

Sugared Cranberries
This unique crowd-pleaser recipe is super easy to make, tastes delicious and looks amazing! Plus it gets a lot of attention at your family get-together.

DIY Christmas Paper Bag Star
This craft is so simple and easy enough for kids or adults to make. Just three simple steps in about 15 minutes and you’re done!

Christmas Morning Muffins
Cranberry orange muffins have become our new Christmas morning tradition along with our reindeer pancakes!

Cranberry Walnut Pie
I love that this recipe has only a few simple ingredients. It is simple and quick to make, it looks beautiful and it tastes like a mixture of cranberry bread and warm vanilla pie.

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Did you love this post?

Want to receive more posts like this one in your inbox—and be the first to know about local deals, ways to save money and fun things to do in Lancaster PA?




Thank you!

Check your email right away. We just sent you a welcome letter with direct links to our most helpful resources in Lancaster County. And tomorrow you’ll get a neat little freebie from us. (Add frugal.lancaster@gmail.com to your address book if you’re having trouble getting the emails!)



  • Classical Conversations

Medieval Family Movie Night Ideas for CC Cycle 2

By Kathy /
Our family loves to enjoy family movie nights thanks to a change I made a few years ago after I...
Read More
Medieval Family Movie Night Ideas for CC Cycle 2
  • Lancaster County

Young Artist classes a la carte is back for 2022: Build your own art camp at the Center for Creative Exploration (PA College of Art and Design)

By Kathy /
This Summer the Center for Creative Exploration (CCE) is offering a buffet of diverse opportunities for weeklong and multi-day youth art classes...
Read More
Young Artist classes a la carte is back for 2022: Build your own art camp at the Center for Creative Exploration (PA College of Art and Design)
  • Classical Conversations

Africa: Morning Time Guide, Read-Aloud List and Family Movie Ideas

By Kathy /
A six-week morning time guide on Africa geography, history, literature, music, family movies and arts and crafts. As I was...
Read More
Africa: Morning Time Guide, Read-Aloud List and Family Movie Ideas
  • Lancaster County

Shopping Lancaster County Etsy Stores

By Kathy /
Support your local creators and vendors this holiday season, by checking out these local Etsy shops. I've made three collections...
Read More
  • Lancaster County

Refreshing Mountain Christmas Lights & Family Escape Room Experience

By Kathy /
Consider a gift of experience this year for the holidays and make some memories with those you love most. You...
Read More
  • Homeschool
  • Lancaster County
  • Local Events
  • Seasonal

7 Summer Theater Camps in Lancaster County

By Kathy /
If your child has the performance bug and wants to learn how to perform on stage, Lancaster County has no...
Read More
7 Summer Theater Camps in Lancaster County
  • Lancaster County

How We Save on Gas

By Kathy /
Where we live, we're about 20 minutes from almost everything. It's a blessing, because you can go so many places...
Read More
How We Save on Gas
  • Food
  • Lancaster County

How to Live Off Of Your Pantry for a Month

By Kathy /
For the month of January 2021, I completed my first ever pantry challenge. What is a pantry challenge? Simply put,...
Read More
How to Live Off Of Your Pantry for a Month
  • Classical Conversations

80+ Etsy Gifts for Classical Conversations Tutors

By Kathy /
I found myself down a little rabbit trail this weekend when I was searching Etsy for some tutor gift ideas....
Read More
80+ Etsy Gifts for Classical Conversations Tutors
  • Lancaster County
  • Recipes
  • Seasonal

Our Family’s Top 10 Favorite Sourdough Recipes

By Kathy /
During the COVID quarantine I saw so many people trying sourdough. I was interested, but it just wasn't the right...
Read More
Our Family’s Top 10 Favorite Sourdough Recipes

Primary Sidebar

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Search

Popular Posts

Medieval Family Movie Night Ideas for CC Cycle 2
10 Fun Indoor Water Parks Near Lancaster County PA
American History Family Movies that Kids Enjoy During CC Cycle 3
Empty Tomb Crescent Rolls {An Easter Family Tradition}
Redner's: FREE Betty Crocker Cake Mix AND $5 credit for your BTFE school
3 Ways to Save on Hershey's Water Works at the Hershey Lodge

Facebook

Facebook

Footer

Frugal Lancaster posts may contain affiliate links, which means we might make a small percentage of sales made through our links (at no extra cost to you!) Please read our privacy policy for more details.

Copyright© 2026 · Brunch Pro Theme by Shay Bocks