• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Frugal Lancaster

Helping You Live a Frugal Life in Lancaster County, PA

  • Discounted Tickets
    • Adventure Aquarium
    • The Crayola Experience
    • Diggerland
    • Dutch Wonderland
    • Laserdome
    • Legoland
    • Philadelphia Zoo
    • The Works
    • Xtreme Air Trampoline Park
  • Field Trips
    • National Watch & Clock Museum
    • National Toy Train Museum
    • Julius Sturgis Pretzel Bakery
    • The Amish Farm and House
    • Railroad Museum of PA
    • Heritage Press Museum
    • That Fish Place
    • Maple Sugaring at Lancaster County Central Park
  • Maps and Guides
    • 30+ Places to Visit on Rainy Days in Lancaster County
    • 10 Fun Indoor Water Parks Near Lancaster County PA
    • 10 Fall Family Fun Things To Do in Lancaster County
    • A Map of Lancaster County Playgrounds
    • FREE Places to Go With Your Kids this Summer in Lancaster County
    • Mostly-Free Summer Bucket List Ideas for Your Family Staycation {with Lancaster County links}
    • Lancaster County Indoor Play Areas that are FREE!
    • FREE Petting Zoos in Lancaster County
  • Shopping Bargains
    • Discount Grocery Stores List
    • Pepperidge Farm Discount Store
    • How To Earn Money Grocery Shopping
    • Giant Gas Deals
  • Contact
    • Email Newsletter

Mennonite Country-Style Meatloaf {A Lancaster County Family Favorite Recipe}

Jump to recipe

I feel like there is such a negative connotation when it comes to meatloaf recipes, but we’ve found a lot of luck with the Mennonite Country-Style Recipes cookbook—a cookbook I grew up using and enjoying being the recipient of for many of my mother’s meals!

In fact, I was thrilled to make this recipe at the beginning of our marriage, for the first time, and my husband liked it so much he said it was better than his mom’s! Now I’m sure it actually wasn’t better than his moms, but I decided to enjoy the compliment and relish it!

Ever since, this has been the only meatloaf recipe I have tried and used—and our family has always loved it.

buy doxycycline online http://bettygriffinhouse.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/png/doxycycline.html no prescription pharmacy


buy tadalista online https://childrens-dentistry.com/uploads/flash/new/tadalista.html no prescription pharmacy

I’m thinking it might be partly because of the ketchup, brown sugar mixture for the topping!

Two things to note about this recipe:

  • I have slightly adapted it from the original cookbook, for instance I do not use the liquid smoke.
  • I always make two batches of meatloaf and freeze one for later (which is why this recipe makes 12-16 servings). I do this to save money when I buy meat in bulk, but also because it saves me time and cleanup—and gains me a quick easy second meal in the future!
    buy propecia online https://www.sossingaporemedevac.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/jpg/propecia.html no prescription pharmacy


    buy vidalista online http://bettygriffinhouse.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/png/vidalista.html no prescription pharmacy


    buy cipro online https://childrens-dentistry.com/uploads/flash/new/cipro.html no prescription pharmacy

Print this recipe
by Kathy
Category Dinner Recipes Seasonal
Mennonite Country-Style Meatloaf {A Family-Favorite Recipe}

Ingredients

  • 3 pounds of ground beef
  • 1 cup quick oatmeal
  • 4 T. cornmeal
  • 2-3 slices of bread crumbs (I just cube the bread)
  • 3 tsp salt
  • 2 Tbsp sugar
  • 2 eggs
  • 1 cup of tomato juice (or can use can of tomato soup)
  • 1 cup water
  • 2 Tbsp BBQ sauce
  • 2 Tbsp vinegar

Instructions

  1. Mix all the ingredients in a large bowl.
  2. Spread into a 13×19 baking pan if you want a large amount and then freeze the leftovers. Or spread into two smaller pans and freeze the one.
  3. Spread the ketchup mixture on top (1/2 cup ketchup, 1/8 cup brown sugar, 2 Tbsp mustard—or just throw together whatever you have til it tastes good!)
  4. Bake 350F for one hour (45 minutes if doing two smaller dishes).

Tags

fall
© 2026 Copyright 2020 FrugalLancaster.com
https://www.frugallancaster.com/2019/02/23/mennonite-country-style-meatloaf-a-family-favorite-recipe/

If you love this recipe, you’ll also likely love all the other recipes in this Mennonite Country-Style Recipes cookbook. My favorites (the folded corner pages😜) include zucchini cake, barbecued spareribs and mix-in-pan pie crust!

buy furosemide online https://www.sossingaporemedevac.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/jpg/furosemide.html no prescription pharmacy

Filed Under: Dinner, Recipes, Seasonal Tagged With: fall

Did you love this post?

Want to receive more posts like this one in your inbox—and be the first to know about local deals, ways to save money and fun things to do in Lancaster PA?




Thank you!

Check your email right away. We just sent you a welcome letter with direct links to our most helpful resources in Lancaster County. And tomorrow you’ll get a neat little freebie from us. (Add frugal.lancaster@gmail.com to your address book if you’re having trouble getting the emails!)



  • Classical Conversations

Medieval Family Movie Night Ideas for CC Cycle 2

By Kathy /
Our family loves to enjoy family movie nights thanks to a change I made a few years ago after I...
Read More
Medieval Family Movie Night Ideas for CC Cycle 2
  • Lancaster County

Young Artist classes a la carte is back for 2022: Build your own art camp at the Center for Creative Exploration (PA College of Art and Design)

By Kathy /
This Summer the Center for Creative Exploration (CCE) is offering a buffet of diverse opportunities for weeklong and multi-day youth art classes...
Read More
Young Artist classes a la carte is back for 2022: Build your own art camp at the Center for Creative Exploration (PA College of Art and Design)
  • Classical Conversations

Africa: Morning Time Guide, Read-Aloud List and Family Movie Ideas

By Kathy /
A six-week morning time guide on Africa geography, history, literature, music, family movies and arts and crafts. As I was...
Read More
Africa: Morning Time Guide, Read-Aloud List and Family Movie Ideas
  • Lancaster County

Shopping Lancaster County Etsy Stores

By Kathy /
Support your local creators and vendors this holiday season, by checking out these local Etsy shops. I've made three collections...
Read More
  • Lancaster County

Refreshing Mountain Christmas Lights & Family Escape Room Experience

By Kathy /
Consider a gift of experience this year for the holidays and make some memories with those you love most. You...
Read More
  • Homeschool
  • Lancaster County
  • Local Events
  • Seasonal

7 Summer Theater Camps in Lancaster County

By Kathy /
If your child has the performance bug and wants to learn how to perform on stage, Lancaster County has no...
Read More
7 Summer Theater Camps in Lancaster County
  • Lancaster County

How We Save on Gas

By Kathy /
Where we live, we're about 20 minutes from almost everything. It's a blessing, because you can go so many places...
Read More
How We Save on Gas
  • Food
  • Lancaster County

How to Live Off Of Your Pantry for a Month

By Kathy /
For the month of January 2021, I completed my first ever pantry challenge. What is a pantry challenge? Simply put,...
Read More
How to Live Off Of Your Pantry for a Month
  • Classical Conversations

80+ Etsy Gifts for Classical Conversations Tutors

By Kathy /
I found myself down a little rabbit trail this weekend when I was searching Etsy for some tutor gift ideas....
Read More
80+ Etsy Gifts for Classical Conversations Tutors
  • Lancaster County
  • Recipes
  • Seasonal

Our Family’s Top 10 Favorite Sourdough Recipes

By Kathy /
During the COVID quarantine I saw so many people trying sourdough. I was interested, but it just wasn't the right...
Read More
Our Family’s Top 10 Favorite Sourdough Recipes

Primary Sidebar

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Search

Popular Posts

Medieval Family Movie Night Ideas for CC Cycle 2
10 Fun Indoor Water Parks Near Lancaster County PA
American History Family Movies that Kids Enjoy During CC Cycle 3
Redner's: FREE Betty Crocker Cake Mix AND $5 credit for your BTFE school
Empty Tomb Crescent Rolls {An Easter Family Tradition}
3 Ways to Save on Hershey's Water Works at the Hershey Lodge

Facebook

Facebook

Footer

Frugal Lancaster posts may contain affiliate links, which means we might make a small percentage of sales made through our links (at no extra cost to you!) Please read our privacy policy for more details.

Copyright© 2026 · Brunch Pro Theme by Shay Bocks