• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Frugal Lancaster

Helping You Live a Frugal Life in Lancaster County, PA

  • Discounted Tickets
    • Adventure Aquarium
    • The Crayola Experience
    • Diggerland
    • Dutch Wonderland
    • Laserdome
    • Legoland
    • Philadelphia Zoo
    • The Works
    • Xtreme Air Trampoline Park
  • Field Trips
    • National Watch & Clock Museum
    • National Toy Train Museum
    • Julius Sturgis Pretzel Bakery
    • The Amish Farm and House
    • Railroad Museum of PA
    • Heritage Press Museum
    • That Fish Place
    • Maple Sugaring at Lancaster County Central Park
  • Maps and Guides
    • 30+ Places to Visit on Rainy Days in Lancaster County
    • 10 Fun Indoor Water Parks Near Lancaster County PA
    • 10 Fall Family Fun Things To Do in Lancaster County
    • A Map of Lancaster County Playgrounds
    • FREE Places to Go With Your Kids this Summer in Lancaster County
    • Mostly-Free Summer Bucket List Ideas for Your Family Staycation {with Lancaster County links}
    • Lancaster County Indoor Play Areas that are FREE!
    • FREE Petting Zoos in Lancaster County
  • Shopping Bargains
    • Discount Grocery Stores List
    • Pepperidge Farm Discount Store
    • How To Earn Money Grocery Shopping
    • Giant Gas Deals
  • Contact
    • Email Newsletter

5 Best Tips for Shopping Fall Consignment Sales

This post is in partnership with Just Between Friends Lancaster. All opinions are my own.

I have shopped numerous consignment sales, at various times of the year, and I’ve determined that shopping fall consignment sales saves me the most money—mostly because of the larger ticket items that I tend to need to purchase during the fall season.

Here are my 5 Best Tips for Shopping Fall Consignment Sales.

1. Plan Ahead & Make a List

At least a week or two before the sale, take the time to go through ALL of your kids clothes. I tend to buy ahead for my kids sizes, so I have bins in their closets with extra clothes for about a year ahead.

I pull those bins down, empty their drawers and closets and sort through EVERYTHING. Anything that doesn’t fit, I give away or set aside to sell. I then put what fits for the fall/winter season back in their drawers and closets.

Do this for each child.

It really does help to do this a few weeks before the sale. In the days ahead, you’ll have it on your mind and be thinking about what they truly need or what you may have forgotten about.

Take inventory of what clothing your children don’t have enough of. Do they have enough dress pants? Jeans? Long sleeve t-shirts? Sweatshirts? Dresses or cardigans? Socks and tights?

What about shoes? Will their sneakers fit through their winter growth spurt? Do they have dress shoes for school concerts and holiday photos?

Make a list of what you will need to shop for, and remember to include sizes! I also make notes (specifically for my daughter) of what pants/leggings she does have, so I remember what will match the colors and patterns she has.

2. Consider Fall & Winter Holiday Needs

One reason it is easy to save a lot at a fall consignment sale, is because of the two main holidays you can shop for.

First, think of Halloween and go through all your costumes. Do you have costumes on hand that fit your children, or will you need to buy them new ones? Unless you typically buy your costumes at the Dollar Tree, you’ll find that you can save a lot of money on costumes at consignment sales—for any age child!

Next, consider Christmas (since you probably don’t have a huge list of purchase needs for Thanksgiving). 🙂 Is it your child’s (or niece or nephews) first Christmas? If so, you might want to pick up a special ornament or keepsake frame.

Are there Christmas gifts that you can shop for at the sale? You can pretty much find any toy, game, puzzle, and even sports gear at heavily discounted prices—many times almost brand new!

3. Don’t Forget Winter Gear

With warm temperatures lasting longer into the start of school and the fall season, its easy to forget to check all your winter gear when you’re making your list. But these can be higher price-point items, which means you will save a lot shopping for these at consignment sales rather than paying retail price when the first snow storm comes.

Do you have winter coats that fit each of your kids? Boots? Gloves? Hats? Snowsuits? It’s always a good idea to have your kids try these things on before you determine if they’ll fit this winter too. Kids grow so quick!

And while you’re checking all the winter gear, you may as well check your shed or garage too. Do you have sleds? Ice skates? Hockey sticks? Inflatable snow tubes? You’d be surprised how many of these items you’ll find at consignment sales.

4. Prioritize Your List

If you have a lot on your lists, prioritize what is most important. What are the crucial and necessary items you’ll need for their wardrobe and the fall/winter season? Move these to the top of your list.

In the middle of your list, keep the normal, everyday items that you’ll definitely want to purchase, but maybe aren’t as expensive as the most important things at the top of your list.

Put extra items, that aren’t necessities, at the bottom of your list. This will help you budget, since you’ll plan to shop the sale in the order of your list. You can keep a mental tally of your total and then save the last items for another time (or come back for those during the 50% off sale at the end of the week!)

5. Shop for Your Most Expensive Ticket Items First

Check your list. Do you have higher price-point ticket items? If so, shop for those first. Look at the floor map when you arrive, and make a mad dash for whats most important to you and what you’d pay most for somewhere else.

If you have a lot of higher price-point ticket items, consider how many items and how much you can save on those items at the consignment sale.

If you’re not a consignor and aren’t eligible for early admission to the sale, it might be worth it for you to purchase the Prime Time presale pass for just $10. It’s worth it if its going to save you!


JBF Lancaster Consignment Sale

Speaking of consignment sales, my favorite Lancaster County consignment sale is coming up in just about two weeks, from October 4-6, 2019. This is the fourth or fifth year of the sale in Lancaster, and every year it grows bigger and better.

The JBF Lancaster Kids Consignment Sale will be held at Spook Nook Lanco, 1901 Miller Road, East Petersburg, PA 17520. Here are the details for sale specific start times:

JBF Presale Info

Tickets are required to shop the presale. There are 3 options—first time parent/grandparent, teachers, and Prime Time ($10 fee). All tickets are FREE with the exception of the Prime Time ticket, but all DO require advance registration).

The pass below waives the $3 registration fee on opening day, Friday, October 4, 2019. Just show it on your phone and you’ll get in for FREE!

For more information, visit the JBF Lancaster website and follow their Facebook page for up-to-date information, reminders and sneak peaks at the sale!

Filed Under: Lancaster County

Did you love this post?

Want to receive more posts like this one in your inbox—and be the first to know about local deals, ways to save money and fun things to do in Lancaster PA?




Thank you!

Check your email right away. We just sent you a welcome letter with direct links to our most helpful resources in Lancaster County. And tomorrow you’ll get a neat little freebie from us. (Add frugal.lancaster@gmail.com to your address book if you’re having trouble getting the emails!)



  • Classical Conversations

Medieval Family Movie Night Ideas for CC Cycle 2

By Kathy /
Our family loves to enjoy family movie nights thanks to a change I made a few years ago after I...
Read More
Medieval Family Movie Night Ideas for CC Cycle 2
  • Lancaster County

Young Artist classes a la carte is back for 2022: Build your own art camp at the Center for Creative Exploration (PA College of Art and Design)

By Kathy /
This Summer the Center for Creative Exploration (CCE) is offering a buffet of diverse opportunities for weeklong and multi-day youth art classes...
Read More
Young Artist classes a la carte is back for 2022: Build your own art camp at the Center for Creative Exploration (PA College of Art and Design)
  • Classical Conversations

Africa: Morning Time Guide, Read-Aloud List and Family Movie Ideas

By Kathy /
A six-week morning time guide on Africa geography, history, literature, music, family movies and arts and crafts. As I was...
Read More
Africa: Morning Time Guide, Read-Aloud List and Family Movie Ideas
  • Lancaster County

Shopping Lancaster County Etsy Stores

By Kathy /
Support your local creators and vendors this holiday season, by checking out these local Etsy shops. I've made three collections...
Read More
  • Lancaster County

Refreshing Mountain Christmas Lights & Family Escape Room Experience

By Kathy /
Consider a gift of experience this year for the holidays and make some memories with those you love most. You...
Read More
  • Homeschool
  • Lancaster County
  • Local Events
  • Seasonal

7 Summer Theater Camps in Lancaster County

By Kathy /
If your child has the performance bug and wants to learn how to perform on stage, Lancaster County has no...
Read More
7 Summer Theater Camps in Lancaster County
  • Lancaster County

How We Save on Gas

By Kathy /
Where we live, we're about 20 minutes from almost everything. It's a blessing, because you can go so many places...
Read More
How We Save on Gas
  • Food
  • Lancaster County

How to Live Off Of Your Pantry for a Month

By Kathy /
For the month of January 2021, I completed my first ever pantry challenge. What is a pantry challenge? Simply put,...
Read More
How to Live Off Of Your Pantry for a Month
  • Classical Conversations

80+ Etsy Gifts for Classical Conversations Tutors

By Kathy /
I found myself down a little rabbit trail this weekend when I was searching Etsy for some tutor gift ideas....
Read More
80+ Etsy Gifts for Classical Conversations Tutors
  • Lancaster County
  • Recipes
  • Seasonal

Our Family’s Top 10 Favorite Sourdough Recipes

By Kathy /
During the COVID quarantine I saw so many people trying sourdough. I was interested, but it just wasn't the right...
Read More
Our Family’s Top 10 Favorite Sourdough Recipes

Primary Sidebar

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Search

Popular Posts

Medieval Family Movie Night Ideas for CC Cycle 2
10 Fun Indoor Water Parks Near Lancaster County PA
American History Family Movies that Kids Enjoy During CC Cycle 3
Redner's: FREE Betty Crocker Cake Mix AND $5 credit for your BTFE school
Empty Tomb Crescent Rolls {An Easter Family Tradition}
3 Ways to Save on Hershey's Water Works at the Hershey Lodge

Facebook

Facebook

Footer

Frugal Lancaster posts may contain affiliate links, which means we might make a small percentage of sales made through our links (at no extra cost to you!) Please read our privacy policy for more details.

Copyright© 2026 · Brunch Pro Theme by Shay Bocks